Pages

Tuesday, May 7, 2013

Business Plan or No Business Plan? That is the Question. Dr. Steve Gedeon vs. Chuck Blakeman


In discussing business plans with “experts” that have been successful in the creation of businesses, I wanted to highlight two contrasting opinions that could serve a young entrepreneur well for future planning.

The Experts

Source: www.siferyerson.com
First, let’s introduce Dr. Steve Gedeon. Here’s the rundown of why he is considered an “expert” in the field of business planning:
·      1st place prizewinner of the 3E Learning Award for his workshop Investment Negotiation
·      Professor in Entrepreneurship and Strategy at Ted Rogers School of Management
·      Expert in business plans – both writer and reviewer
·      Motivational Speaker and Coach
·      Venture Capitalist
·      MS and PhD from Massachusetts Institute of Technology

I could have continued with his list, but for the sake of time, you can just visit his accomplishments at his educator’s page

Source: si0,twimg.com
The second expert we will observe is Chuck Blakeman. Here’s a brief overview of why he was chosen:
·      Internationally acclaimed business speaker
·      Featured in Entrepreneur Magazine, CNNMoney.com, NYTimes.com, and various other business blogs and online magazines
·      Founded and owns the Crankset Group, which works with businesses owners
·      Started and built seven successful businesses in 25 years in U.S. and internationally

Source: http://www.betadaily.com
The Plans

Dr. Steve Gedeon and Chuck Blakeman differ tremendously, which is why I chose to spotlight what each considers in a business plan to be the most critical component. Their accomplishments, businesses and education already demonstrate their different outlooks on what makes a business successful.

            Dr. Steve Gedeon
In an interview with Dr. Steve Gedeon, he mentions that some businesses really don’t need to write a business plan, they can just go out there and do it. 

That aside, he is clearly an advocate for business plans (FYI: that’s what he teaches); they play a key role for specific reasons, especially for raising finance. A business plan provides credibility to potential investors and shows them you understand your market and product or service. 

Now, the critical component that Dr. Gedeon says is key is the Executive Summary. “Most people won’t go beyond the Executive Summary, so that needs to be the main catcher.”

In writing the business plan, he believes the actual writing is not as important as the thought process of what makes a successful business. Once people have that down, he believes the business plan will write itself.

            Chuck Blakeman

On the flipside, Chuck Blakeman is not a fan of planning, much less business plans. In an article on his website, How, the worst, most asked planning question, Chuck mentions that, 
“A Harvard researcher found that 97% of all businesses leave their prime objective in order to be objective. The world’s greatest past and present businesses (Apple, Google, Facebook, HP, 37signals, etc.) all started out to do something other than what they ended up doing. And none of them did much pre-planning, if any.”
He goes on to say that even those that “wasted time pre-planning” ended up going a different direction in their business (i.e. Ben & Jerry).

Blakeman’s key point is to focus on short-term planning and consistently asking the “how” question throughout the lifespan of the business.

One of my favorite quotes from his article is when he says, “Life and business are too fluid to ask long-term “how”. Keep “how” for the short-term.”

He’s not against planning, he just doesn’t believe in long-term planning.

Personally, I’m a fan of Chuck Blakeman, his concepts on business and his outlook. He’s great at social media; he’s a wonderful and enthusiastic speaker, and he tells it straight.

Follow 

To keep up with these two entrepreneur experts, follow them on Twitter here:

No comments:

Post a Comment